📝 Comparing AI Writing Tools: Gemini, GPT-4, and GPT-4o for Business

Introduction

You've probably heard about this new AI technology that can write like humans. It's pretty wild stuff! For businesses and marketing teams, generative AI tools are seriously game-changing.

These AI Writing Tools, called large language models or LLMs for short, can basically read and understand text just like we do. But then they can use that understanding to do all sorts of cool things - like automating writing tasks, analyzing data, even coming up with completely new ideas and creative content.

The crazy part is that not all LLMs work exactly the same way. Some are better at straightforward writing tasks, while others are more analytical. Certain ones tend to communicate in a really academic, complex way, while others write more like how you and I might speak to a friend.

It's kind of like having multiple humans with different specialities and communication styles, except they're hyper-intelligent AI instead of people! That's what makes generative AI such a powerful tool for businesses - you can pick and choose which "AI person" is best suited for the job at hand.

I. Interfaces and Ease of Use for Each AI Writing Tool

1. Gemini Advanced

Features:

• Multiple Drafts: It doesn't just give you one response - Gemini generates three different options for each prompt you give it. That way, you have a higher chance of getting something really close to what you need.

  

• Editing Capabilities: Let's say you like most of what Gemini wrote, but there's a specific section you want to tweak. You can highlight just that part and ask it to "regenerate" or rewrite only that snippet, while keeping the rest intact.

  

  mak

• Customization: Using special menus, you can customize the tone of Gemini's writing to be more casual and conversational or more professional and formal. You can also adjust the target length by entering a desired word count.

  

• Integration: Gemini works hand-in-hand with Google's apps. You can export writing directly into a Google Doc or draft an email in Gmail - super convenient!

• Fact-Checking: This is a unique feature - Gemini lets you compare its output side-by-side with search results from Google. It will highlight any overlapping text as well as potential inaccuracies.

  

Limitations:

• Limited Editing History: Unfortunately, Gemini only keeps track of the most recent thing you asked it to write. You can't easily go back and re-work prompts from earlier in the conversation.

• Single Draft View: After you select one of those initial three drafts Gemini gave you, the other two options disappear from view. You can't re-visit them unless you start that prompt over from scratch.

Summary: 

All in all, Gemini's interface is really user-friendly and packed with handy features that give you a lot of control over the writing. The few downsides are relatively minor inconveniences rather than dealbreakers. It's an awesome AI writing assistant that saves tons of time and effort.

2. GPT-4 and GPT-4o

Features:

• Comprehensive Editing History: This is really handy - you can go back and re-work anything you previously asked the AI to write, not just the latest thing. Makes it easier to refine and improve over multiple rounds.

• Plugin Ecosystem: GPT-4 connects to a huge library of tools created by developers and partner companies. These plugins give it extra super powers for tasks like research, data analysis, and productivity hacks.

Limitations:

• Lack of Granular Editing: Unlike Gemini, you can't just highlight a small section to re-write. If you want to modify something in the middle of the text, you have to generate the whole thing again from scratch.

• Exporting Limitations: Getting your writing out of GPT-4 in different file formats like Word docs or spreadsheets isn't very straightforward. You have to use workarounds to copy/paste things over.

Summary:

The GPT-4 models have a ton of capabilities overall. But when it comes to editing and moving your content elsewhere, some of Gemini's features make the process smoother.

II. Content Production of Each AI Writing Tool

1. Factual Accuracy

• Challenge: Sometimes these AI Writing Tools can get facts wrong or even completely contradict themselves. It's kinda like how humans can make mistakes too.

• Advice: Always double-check the information, especially if it's about something you don't know much about already. A quick fact check can prevent spreading misinformation.

2. Writing Style

Gemini:

• Concise Summaries: Gemini is great at cutting out the fluff and just giving you the main points in a clear, straightforward way.

• Natural Sounding: The writing feels really natural, like how a person would explain something simply. Easy to read and understand.

• Time-Saving: Because Gemini's initial drafts are so clean, I don't have to spend as much time revising and tweaking the text.

GPT-4:

• In-Depth Explanations: This model dives deeper into topics with more detailed, nuanced writing. Works well for research-heavy or analytical content.

• Complexity: The complex academic language can sometimes make GPT-4's output harder to work with right away.

Personal Experience: For me, Gemini is usually the way to go when I need natural-sounding writing that doesn't require a ton of editing passes.

3. Creative Writing

• Observation: All the AI models showed at least some creative spark when I tested fiction writing, poetry, dialogue etc.

• Gemini Strength: But Gemini really stood out with its imaginative plots and emotional storytelling ability.

• Advice: Try out multiple models yourself to see which one best fits your creative writing needs.

4. Content Repurposing

Gemini:

• Audience Awareness: Gemini does a great job at adjusting its writing voice to hit the right tone for different audiences.

• Limitations: However, when I tried having it summarize content from websites by pasting links, Gemini struggled. Sometimes it misunderstood the source material and gave inaccurate summaries.

GPT-4:

• Format Flexibility: The GPT models can easily adapt writing to new formats like video scripts, email sequences, social media posts, etc.

• Web Savvy: These AIs have no trouble at all analyzing content from almost any website link you share. The summaries tend to be comprehensive and accurate.

Summary: If you need to repurpose web content into different materials, the GPT models like GPT-4 are the better tools for the job. Gemini's link limitations make it less reliable for those kinds of tasks.

5. Prompt Understanding

• Challenge: These AI Writing Tools can get tripped up if you give them super long, complex instructions all at once. They may miss or misunderstand certain parts.

• Technique: The best way to avoid confusion is using something called "Iterative Prompt Development." Basically:

  1. Start with a simple prompt

  2. See what the AI writes

  3. Tweak the prompt to improve the output

  4. Repeat until you get the ideal result

• Personal Strategy: I find myself going back-and-forth quite a bit, testing out slightly different prompts each time. Adding extra details, removing some, rewriting with new wording, etc.

It takes some trial-and-error, but this iterative process helps me understand exactly how much hand-holding each AI needs to produce great content. Over time, crafting effective prompts becomes second nature.

6. Translations

• Gemini Strength: When it comes to translating between languages, Gemini seems to have an edge at really nailing those cultural nuances and idioms.

• GPT-4o Superpower: The new GPT-4o model is crazy impressive for real-time translation right on your mobile device. In my tests, it could accurately understand speech in one language and instantly speak the translation out loud in another. Wild!

• Potential Use: I can see a tool like GPT-4o being a total game-changer for industries where language barriers are an issue - like airlines, hotels, customer support centers etc. Back when I used to work in a call center, we'd sometimes struggle to help customers because of language differences. Having an AI translator that good would have allowed us to communicate with so many more people across the world. Talk about opening up new markets!

III. Additional Functions of These AI Writing Tools

1. Code

• Experience:

  • GPT-4o: This model was the speediest and most accurate when I asked it to generate code for me, like HTML for a website.

  • Gemini: Frustratingly, Gemini often flat-out refused coding tasks, saying it wasn't capable of that.

• Advice: No matter which AI you use, always double-check the code it produces. I've seen mistakes slip through even with clear instructions.

2. Charts

• Comparison:

  • GPT-4: The most limited in terms of chart customization. You can only save the viz as a static image.

  • GPT-4o: Gives you a bit more flexibility to make minor design tweaks to things like colors and labels.

  • Gemini: The most versatile option. You can change chart types, edit axes, and even export data directly to Google Sheets.

• All three handled basic data analysis decently though, so could be useful for finance/accounting.

3. Image Generation

• Preference: For visuals like social media graphics, GPT-4 (DALL-E) is my go-to. It offers different format options and generally high quality results.

• Challenges:

  • Intricate details tend to get lost or look blurred

  • Hands and fingers often look weirdly artificial

  • Text within the images can be hard to read or incorrect

4. File Analysis

• Gemini Strength: Impressively, Gemini could analyze and summarize videos (with captions), Excel files, images, and PDFs for me.

• GPT Limitation: GPT-4 and GPT-4o seem limited to just images and PDFs currently. They couldn't process YouTube links or Google Sheets in my tests.

Conclusion

Working with AI writing tools like Gemini, GPT-4, and GPT-4o has definitely been an interesting learning experience. One of the biggest takeaways is that while this technology is incredibly powerful, it's not a magic solution that can just do everything perfectly on its own.

You still need to put in the effort to guide the AI models and carefully review their outputs. Things can go off the rails if you don't provide clear prompts and instructions tailored to each tool's strengths. But when you take the time to really understand the AI's capabilities and how to leverage them, the payoff is huge.

Looking ahead, I'm really excited to see how generative AI continues advancing and becoming integrated into more professional workflows. If you can harness these tools effectively, you'll not only operate way more efficiently yourself, but free up brainpower to focus on higher-level creative and strategic efforts. The future of work is AI-augmented for sure.

If you are interested in other topics and how AI is transforming different aspects of our lives, or even in making money using AI with more detailed, step-by-step guidance, you can find our other articles here:

• AI Friend for Frontend Developers: Build UIs Faster and Easier

• 20 AI Startups Raise over $2.2B (May 17, 2024 - May 25, 2024)*

• How to Build Your Own AI Assistant: Easy Guide for Text and Voice*

• Build Smart AI Assistants and Chatbots Without Coding for Free*

• ElevenLabs' New AI Music Tool - Awesome or Stealing from Artists?

_{*indicates a premium content, if any}